When I tried to protect my 5-year-old daughter from my father, my sister and mother forced me away while my father yelled, “Your trashy little thing needs to learn manners.” Then he began hitting her with a belt until she stopped moving.

And every time, Lily tried harder.

She behaved like someone much older than five. She watched faces. She measured reactions. She smiled carefully, like a performer trying to earn applause. She shared her toys. She said “please” and “thank you.” She complimented my mother’s dress even when my mother barely acknowledged her.

Lily believed perfection could buy safety.

That belief almost killed her.

The Sunday Gathering

That summer Sunday began like all the others: deceptively normal.

My father stood at the grill flipping burgers, beer in hand, scowl carved permanently into his face. He’d always worn anger like armor. Growing up, I learned early to read his moods the way people read weather. You could feel a storm coming before the first word was spoken.

My mother hovered near Vanessa, praising her famous potato salad like it was a sacred offering. Vanessa thrived in that attention. She always did. She had the kind of entitlement that grows when everyone around you keeps saying you deserve more.

Derek held court by the picnic table, lecturing about interest rates and stock returns to anyone who couldn’t escape. He was the type of man who confused being loud with being right.

The kids ran through the sprinklers, shrieking with the kind of joy children are born knowing. My cousins played, tumbled, shouted. Lily stayed close to my side, her small hand brushing mine as if she needed to keep contact to feel steady.

I remember thinking, She’s being so good today.

Continue reading…